Burton P. Guidry & Associates
Personal Injury Newsletter
Preparing for a Personal Injury Suit
Lawyers have, in recent years, acquired a reputation for not returning
phone calls and criticized for not informing their clients of what is going on
with the client’s case. We hope to avoid you thinking either of those about our
firm. We have prepared this document for
your general information. Of course we welcome specific questions, but this
should answer most questions about what is likely to happen in your case.
The gathering of
documentary evidence at the early stage of the case is very important.
3. All hospital, medical and related bills, either paid or unpaid (physicians, surgeons, ambulance, hospitals, private nursing care, therapy, drugs/medication, crutches, braces, X‑rays, domestic help, car rental, clothing, etc.);
4. Income tax returns for the last five years;
5. Your health and accident insurance policy or policies;
6. Insurance policy that may require aid of attorney to notify and collect (income protection, hospitalization, etc.);
7. Copies of any statements previously made to anyone (opposing side, your insurance carrier, etc.);
8. Repair bill on any damaged property;
9. Repair estimates on any damaged property;
10.Purchase invoices and estimates of value of personal property damaged or lost in accident (including clothing, jewelry, cameras, and all other property damaged in accident);
11. Correspondence with insurance company, insurance adjusters;
12. Business cards from insurance company agents and adjusters, opposing driver, etc.;
13. Copy of any accident reports;
14. Statement from employer regarding lost wages showing time and wages lost from work;
15. Copies of check stubs and/or other records showing hourly rate of pay;
16. Copies of any application for other insurance benefits;
17. Copy of any application for unemployment benefits;
18. A Copy of your social security card.
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS:
1. Do not talk to any insurance adjuster without one of us being present;
2. Do not discuss the facts of the accident with anyone before having your first conference with the attorney;
3. Do not sign anything without your attorney's permission;
4. Keep a diary of your trips to all doctors, hospitals, therapists and notes of your pain with times and dates;
5. Keep all your medicine bottles and containers (as possible evidence at trial);
6. Bring or send all future medical bills to your attorney's office;
7. When you return to treating physicians for follow‑ up examinations, be sure to advise them at each examination the nature of all of your continuing problems resulting from the accident.
8. Keep a record of all out‑of‑pocket expenses, including travel expenses for medical treatment;
9. Report to your attorney any suspicious actions, such as someone taking pictures, movies, etc.
WHAT WILL HAPPEN IN YOUR CASE
The purpose of this section is to familiarize you with the way your case will be handled and to tell you how you can help us to obtain justice for you. After you have read the booklet and the checklist contained in it, if you have any questions, do not hesitate to get in touch with us, and we will do the best we can to answer them.
THE FIRST STEPS
Shortly after the first interview with you and when we have accepted the case, a file will be established and assigned to one of our investigators and/or attorneys under the supervision of one of our trial lawyers. That person will then begin extensive investigation. In most cases, he will interview you and obtain a statement from any of the witnesses that may exist. He is expected to obtain photographs and to assemble all of the information that is available as to how the accident occurred and who is responsible. He will probably obtain pictures of the accident scene, and of your injuries before bruises, lacerations, etc., have had a chance to disappear.
While the investigator/attorney is conducting his investigation, our office will prepare a letter to each of your physicians and will request medical records. However, in some cases, we may wish to personally interview the attending physician prior to the time we request a written report from him.
One of the first things the insurance company will wish to have from us is a list of special damages which are incurred by you. By special damages, they mean out‑of‑pocket expenses such as doctor bills, hospital bills, medical bills, any loss of earnings or income that occurred as a result of the accident, and any property damages that may have resulted.
You should refrain from discussing the details of your accident or injuries with persons not entitled to that information. Any inquiries from the person responsible for your injuries or their representatives should be referred to your attorney. If the insurance company representative comes to you, inform him you are represented by our law firm and REFER HIM TO US for any information he seeks. DO NOT MAKE ANY STATEMENTS TO THAT PERSON WITHOUT SPECIFIC PERMISSION FROM YOUR ATTORNEY.
If you have already made statements to any insurance company representative, or anyone else, tell us immediately of these statements and the contents of the statements, and furnish us with a copy if you have one in your possession.
YOUR DOCTOR
It is our belief that you are entitled to the very best of medical care available in order to effect a cure or to minimize the permanent effects of your injury. It is essential that you assist us in obtaining copies of all bills and receipts for all expenditures made by you. The pecuniary loss suffered by you is sometimes less important than the effects of the injury on your life.
We will need your assistance in keeping us informed of the effects of the accident on your life and in furnishing us with information as to where we can obtain credible and admissible testimony to prove the effects of the injury on your life.
As we have stated, you are entitled to the best of medical care for conditions caused by the accident, and certainly the person who is at fault should be compelled to pay for it. It is important that you continue to go to a doctor as long as your injuries continue to bother you. You should cooperate with your doctor in every way and should relate to him truthfully and fully all symptoms that you have which arise from or were affected by the accident. You should, of course, answer fully all questions he puts to you. You should realize that medical treatment often takes time to obtain results, and often the possibility of a doctor's diagnosis being accurate is improved by opportunities for improved examination. You cannot expect a doctor to give effective testimony as to your conditions at time of trial if several months elapsed since he last examined you, as obviously he would not be able to state what the condition was at the time of trial. Moreover, insurance companies will often treat the failure to obtain medical treatment as evidence of no injury on the part of the client or an early cure.
Naturally, we do not wish you to fake or exaggerate anything, but as long as there is anything legitimately wrong with you, in order to facilitate the doctors in making their diagnosis and to avoid a distortion of your medical picture by the insurance companies, we believe you should continue to obtain medical care.
We are particularly interested in your keeping us informed as to how rapidly you recover from the injuries which you received. One of the nightmares that haunts every professional trial attorney is the possibility that he will at some time settle or try a case and then subsequently find out that there were additional injuries of which he had no knowledge, or conditions of which he had no knowledge, for which no recovery was made.
Obviously, one of the most significant factors affecting the value of your lawsuit is whether or not we can establish by the testimony of a physician that you have suffered a permanent injury because of the accident.
Doctors know from experience that the full extent of a person's injuries sometimes is not known for several months after an accident. We will be in close communication with your doctors while they are in the process of treating you, and will be monitoring the medical aspect of your case until your doctors are able to give us an opinion concerning this important question.
Please do not talk about your case or your lawyers when you see your
doctor. If you do talk about your case
with the doctor, the doctor may get the wrong idea, and think that you are more
concerned about collecting money than you are about getting well. In addition, most doctors are hesitant to
treat clients of personal injury lawyers for fear of having to testify in
court, so please do not volunteer any information that is not asked to you
about the legal aspects of your medical problem.
WHAT IS MY CASE WORTH?
Some insurance companies, in cases where the liability is clear, relate the value of a case to the "special damages." This is often an unrealistic manner of evaluation since your major damages might be factors such as physical pain and suffering, loss of capacity to lead a normal life, and other factors which do not cause actual bills to be incurred by you.
After we have assembled all of the information that is necessary, we will sit down and make the best and most intelligent estimate, of which we are capable, of the least jury verdict we could obtain, the highest jury verdict we could obtain, and the probable jury verdict. Once this is done, and then we evaluate all the evidence we have available to determine our chances of obtaining a judgment in your favor.
In those cases where there is some question whether or not we can win, we think it is necessary or desirable to discount the probable jury verdict by the percentage of our chances of winning. For example, if we estimate in some hypothetical case that we might obtain a jury verdict in the amount of $10,000.00, but that we had only a fifty‑fifty chance of winning, we believe that for settlement purposes the value of the case is approximately $5,000.00.
AUTOMOBILE ACCIDENTS
If your case involves an automobile accident, there are special factors that influence the value of your case. These factors will also affect whether or not we will be able to file suit on your behalf.
As you may know, if you are involved in an automobile accident case, there are many situations where the driver of the other vehicle had no automobile insurance or had automobile insurance in the least amount that can be carried.
It is therefore necessary for us to know whether or not you have a policy of automobile liability insurance and whether you have purchased uninsured motorist coverage on that policy. In Louisiana, an injured person is permitted to make a claim for his pain and suffering against his own insurance company if he had uninsured motorist coverage. If you have purchased such coverage your attorney will want to see your policy and the declarations page that goes along with it showing such coverage.
We wish that we had the opportunity to tell all of our clients before automobile accidents occur that uninsured motorist coverage is one of the most important automobile insurance coverage you can buy. It is only by this coverage that you can guarantee a source of recovery for yourself or your family for the negligence of another driver. You will also find that uninsured motorist coverage is relatively inexpensive.
In these shaky economic times, many insurance companies are going out of business for one reason or another. Your uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage could prevent a great delay in recovering your damages from the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association, which only covers certain policies anyway.
We now recommend to all of our clients that, in the future, they should
purchase a minimum of $100,000.00 in uninsured motorist coverage on each of the
vehicles they own.
THE LAWSUIT
If it should become necessary to file suit, the procedure is somewhat as follows:
You are the Plaintiff. A Complaint or Petition is filed on your behalf which states the reasons why we believe you have a cause of action against the Defendant, and it sets forth the various claims we are making.
The Defendant has fifteen days from the time he is served with the suit
papers in which to answer. Usually, the Defendant will answer and deny
responsibility and deny that you were injured to the extent described in the
Complaint. Often, the Defendant will
claim that you contributed to your own injuries.
HOW MUCH MONEY ARE WE GOING TO SUE FOR?
One of the more frequent questions asked by new clients is, "How much are we going to sue for?"
In many states, this is a necessary decision and presents a considerable problem to the client and to the trial attorney. In those states where this is a problem, if the attorney fails to sue for enough money and it is discovered that the client is more badly injured than was first believed, the client may be prevented from obtaining full justice because of the fact that the lawsuit was brought for too little money. If, on the other hand, too large a sum is sued for and the client makes a more rapid or complete recovery than was first anticipated, it may well present the image to a judge or jury of a client who is seeking to obtain more than they are entitled to.
Fortunately, in Louisiana, an attorney is not compelled to make this decision prior to filing suit since our laws permit them to sue for "an amount in excess of the minimal jurisdiction of the court," which, in most instances, is nominal.
Since this practice is followed, we are thus able to recover whatever sum is proportionate to the nature and extent of your injuries.
WE DO HOWEVER NEED TO LIST THE ITEMS OF SPECIFIC DAMAGES DISCUSSED PREVIOUSLY AND SHOULD BE ABLE TO TALLY THOSE AMOUNTS PRIOR TO FILING SUIT.
During the course of the lawsuit, we will be permitted to take testimony under oath from all witnesses and doctors who may be involved in the case.
The attorneys for the Defendant will send you written questions known as Interrogatories, which must be answered under oath in writing within fifteen days. The attorney for the Defendant will also take your deposition testimony. However, before either of these things occur, we will make sure that you are familiar with these procedures and that you are thoroughly prepared.
There are certain items of damages you are entitled to recover in most lawsuits. Some of them are as follows:
1.
Past pain and suffering;
2.
Future pain and suffering;
3.
Loss of income;
4.
Future loss of income and diminution of earning capacity;
5.
All out‑of‑pocket expenses, such as doctor bills, other medical bills
and property damage;
6.
Loss of consortium on behalf of the non‑injured spouse; that is, loss of
the services the injured spouse in all the ways a spouse renders service to his
or her mate, including housekeeping, lawn mowing, maintenance, cooking,
companionship and sexual relations.
HOW MUCH IS MY CASE WORTH?
In attempting to evaluate your case, there are many important factors involved, and two of the most important are:
1. How certain are we that we can win for you and make the other side pay for the damages they have caused.
2. How much were you injured; in other words, what is the extent of the damage.
Naturally, a person who has received a serious and crippling injury is entitled to recover more money than an individual who had received only minor injuries, assuming that we have the same certitude of winning. However, in every instance, the chances of winning are only one of the several factors which are considered in evaluating your claim.
The background and history of the parties to the litigation, the jurisdiction in which the case will be tried and appealed as well as others also are considered.
Rest assured we will not settle your claim without your permission as, of course, you know from the terms of our employment agreement.
At some future date when we know all of the factors we can possibly ascertain concerning the value of your case, we will wish to advise you as to that value so that you may make an informed decision concerning whether you wish to settle your case or go to trial.
Any offers to settle your case will be put to you in writing for your acceptance or rejection.
Please do not hesitate to ask us any questions that may occur to you or call us should you care to do so at any time.
We will do our best to represent you fairly and aggressively, and we will keep you informed of the developments in the case.
Casual and instant phone contact with professionals is sometimes
difficult, but we try to maintain communication by offering scheduling of phone
appointments and evening or weekend appointments.
HOW CAN I HELP AND PARTICIPATE IN MY CASE ?
Here is a list of a number of things you can do to help us. These things
are very important, and the list should be reviewed frequently so that you can
keep us up to date on these matters.
CHECKLIST OF THINGS TO DO:
1. It will be most helpful if you will keep a daily diary of your activities with emphasis on restriction of your activities caused by your injuries, specific pains and the frequency of them, frequency of medication taken, and kind of medication. A diary such as this would be useful to you at the trial to refresh your memory as to occurrences that otherwise might be forgotten.
2. Be sure to keep all physical objects such as shoes, clothing, etc., that you had on at the time of the accident. We may need them as evidence at the trial.
3. Be sure you have accurately and completely filled out our interview sheet.
4. Forward to our office itemized
receipts of:
a. Hospital bills
b. Doctor bills
c. Ambulance bills
d. Nursing bills
e. Drug (medicine) bills
f. All other expenses you incurred as a result of the accident,
including:
i. Travel to and from the doctors' offices and hospitals. Keep a
notebook record of these expenses.
ii. Additional help around home and/or business (including baby sitters, if applicable, and domestic or yard help). Keep a notebook record of these expenses.
5. Please tell your drug store from which you purchase prescriptions to be certain that the bills which are furnished to you include only medicines which are related to the accident. In the event they should inadvertently include some other medicine or other household items such as talcum powder, etc., on your bill, the inclusion of this bill would be used by the insurance company to embarrass you at the time of trial to make it appear that you are seeking something to which you are not entitled.
In the event you are using nonprescription drugs, such as aspirin, which are purchased in bottles or other containers, please save these containers since we may wish to introduce them into evidence at the time of trial as proof of the quantity of aspirin or other nonprescription drugs which you have taken.
6. List the names of any neighbors, friends, fellow employees or relatives who knew of your activities both before and after the accident including their names, addresses, phone numbers and what they may know or say about you.
Finally, as you think of information that should be added to this list, please get in touch with us. We will need this information to do a better job for you.
We thank you for considering our firm for representation of your interests in this matter and would like to take the opportunity here to sincerely thank you for the chance to work for you.
This information is offered at no cost and may be freely copied and distributed without royalties with the permission of Burton Guidry.
"Louisiana's Lawyer"
Accepting Cases Statewide
Aggressive
and Effective Representation
Payment Plans Available
Burton P. Guidry & Associates
111 Concord St., Suite B
Abbeville, Louisiana 70510
Ph. 337-740-0834
Fax 888-332-4880
burton@burtonguidryatty.com